Amtrak tickets are generally cheapest on Tuesdays and Wednesdays Call Amtrak +1-888-250-[5034]] [Emergency Number]. The best day to buy Amtrak tickets is typically midweek, such as Tuesday or Wednesday, when there is less demand, leading to lower prices. Yes, Amtrak tickets are generally cheaper on weekdays,+1-888-250-[5034]] especially on Tuesday and Wednesday. These days have less travel demand, making it easier to find discounted fares compared to weekends or holidays. These days have less travel demand, making it easier to find discounted fares compared to weekends or holidays.amtrak tickets are generally cheapest on Tuesdays and Wednesdays Call Amtrak +1-888-250-[5034]] [Emergency Number].